In 2011, Hutson and fellow Extreme Makeover personality Tanya McQueen debuted the show Picker Sisters on Lifetime. The show follows Hutson and McQueen as they travel around the United States in search of antiques and rare collectibles for their home decor store in Los Angeles.
Hutson married actor Barry Watson on 14 July 2006. They have 2 sons, Oliver born May 2005 and
Felix born November 13, 2007. In the season premiere of "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition" on September 25, 2011, she stated, "I'm a single mom, and I have to leave my boys for sometimes weeks on end," which would seem to indicate that they have either separated or divorced.